Robertson for...Rudy? Print E-mail
By Jesse Lava
Nov. 07, 07 13:33

Are the end times upon us?  Or is it just business as usual from the religious right?

 

Pat Robertson — anti-gay, anti-abortion, anti-separation crusader — has endorsed Rudy Giuliani, the pro-gay, pro-choice, non-churchgoing, cross-dressing, twice-divorced, adulterous Republican candidate for president. 

 

Seems ironic, but it’s really not.  Unreformed religious righties like Pat Robertson have long been more concerned with power than principle.  They married the Republicans long ago, despite the party’s anti-biblical stances on poverty, war, the environment, race, and workers’ rights. 

 

It was all about values, we were told — abortion, gays, prayer in school, condoms, whatever.  But the Republicans’ failure to deliver on these supposedly critical issues while ripping the Bible apart on others belies their opposition to anything resembling a Christian worldview.  The religious right, of course, supported them anyway, thereby eradicating any pretext that these hacks may once have had of serving as a prophetic voice in the public arena.

 

Accordingly, Rudy does have one thing to recommend him to the religious right: the political winds happen to be blowing in his direction at the moment.  That is, his national poll numbers look good;  therefore he's the religious right's man.  Q.E.D.

 

To be fair, Pat Robertson hasn’t been taken seriously among most religious conservatives for a while now.  Too much crazy, too little action.  But the guy still has a strong following on his TV network, and he remains an icon.  For him to endorse the likes of Rudy Giuliani reflects the abject cynicism of the religious right’s old guard.  They use hot-button cultural issues to get the masses on their side, then abandon those principles at the first whiff of an invitation to the inaugural ball.


LIST OF COMMENTS

1/6. Sized Him Up Correctly
Written by George  | Nov. 07, 07 14:43
I think that you have correctly interpreted Rev Robertson's motivation. There's a huge temptation for those in the religious arena to compromise whatever principles they might have advanced in order to maintain access to the highest political tiers. I think that Robertson has concluded that Rudy is the only Republican who stands a chance of winning in November, and he is counting on his early endorsement to provide him with invitations to the Oval Office during Gulinai's term. To a certain extent, Rudy has provided a few crumbs of encouragement (Supreme Court nominations etc). I would characterize the relationship between the Religious Right and the Republican Party as symbiotic in nature; that is each is using the other to a certain extent. For example, there are few Republican office-holders who are proposing a Constitutional Amendment to ban all abortions. Why not? If they really in their heart of hearts consider it to be murder, altering the Constitution settles it beyond the power of any branch of government. The Religious Right have consistently backed every Republican presidential candidate since Reagan; the Supreme Court is now populated with judges mainly placed there by Republican presidents; and they are no closer to outlawing abortion than they were 30 years ago. Robertson and the rest of his demagogues are using these issues the same way that the racist southern politicians used school integration during the 50s and 60s.

2/6. You're too kind
Written by Dan Nejfelt  | Nov. 07, 07 15:03
I was about to say you're shooting fish in a barrel.
I was about to say you're beating a dead horse.
I was about to say you're picking on a tired old man.
But no, no, he still deserves it, and you do it well.

3/6. Sad but True
Written by Beth Dahlman  | Nov. 07, 07 15:10

Jesse, I think you're right on with this (and in fact, I have written so myself) and speaking for myself, I am more than happy to see traditional culture wars issues fall farther down the radar.  What prevents me from doing an all-out I told you so dance is this quote:

Robertson said national security and concerns about federal spending should be top priorities. "To me, the overriding issue before the American people is the defense of our population from the blood lust of Islamic terrorists,"

Clearly, there are some on the right who want to use Muslims in 2008 as they used gay and lesbian people in 2004; I hope this time around progressives are better prepared.


4/6. Alex
Written by Carpenter  | Nov. 07, 07 18:02
Jesse, I think that you nailed it.

. . .But the Republicans’ failure to deliver on these supposedly critical issues while ripping the Bible apart on others belies their opposition to anything resembling a Christian worldview.

5/6. Thank You
Written by Adam Parish  | Nov. 07, 07 19:14
Thanks for putting into words how crazy the Robertson / Rudy alliance is.  It's sad for Robertson, because now everyone really knows he's not the principle-centered person he thinks he is.

I've actually gained respect for James Dobson as he has stood on *his* principles and has refused to endorse; Rudy, Thompson, or Romney because of his beliefs.  Even if I disagree with his priorities, I can respect his consistency.

6/6. Uneven Scales
Written by Billy Strain  | Nov. 08, 07 10:35

Through the years, I've been amazed how those in the Religious Right have been able to close ranks behind candidates in the GOP, even when a close examination of their record or stands shows that they don't measure up to their standards.  But they'll do it, though, in the name of political expediency.  Much of what Gulliani has done or supports are the very things that the Religious Right has taken Democrats to task for.  Meanwhile, Democrats who show level of moral integrity or support stands that people of faith could find acceptable are usually met with suspicion by these people.  It will be interesting, though, to see if Dobson and others will stick to their promise not to support Guilliani or even support a third party candidate, like maybe Huckabee.  But, odds are,it's more likely they'll go back to their default position of supporting the Republican nominee whoever he is. 

Billy Strain


Last Updated ( Nov. 07, 07 15:52 )
 
< Prev   Next >